Frozen Yogurt Recipe with Pineapple and Coconut {Low Fat, High Protein, GF + Super Simple)

This quick and easy frozen yogurt recipe is healthy and made with coconut milk, Greek yogurt and pineapple. Perfect for Summer!

Pineapple Coconut Frozen Yogurt - A super easy, healthy dessert for Summer! | Food Faith Fitness| #frozenyogurt #recipe #healthy

Mr. FFF has decided that he can tell the future.

We were out for dinner on the weekend, and I asked him if he was going to get a white or whole wheat hamburger bun with his burger (he didn’t pick the right answer. Sadness.)

When, I asked him this question, he seemed to have a mini panic attack, and started freaking out.

I was concerned.  I didn’t want people to think we were weird.

Oh, you thought I was concerned about him? I got over that after we hit our first anniversary.


Moving on.

Pineapple Coconut Frozen Yogurt - A super easy, healthy dessert for Summer! | Food Faith Fitness| #frozenyogurt #recipe #healthy

So, I asked him what was the matter? Did he have a traumatizing hamburger bun incident as a child, that I was never informed of? I did not know.

You know what his answer was?

“I just had this FEELING that you were going to ask me that. This happens so much to me, I seriously think that I can tell the future.”

OK hubberoni. You just keep telling yourself.  It could not be the fact that I always ask you about making a healthier choice. Definitely NOT THAT.

At least life with that man is never boring.

Hmm, now how to segue way this Frozen Yogurt in to my story?

I could lie and tell you that we went home and ate it, but I made this a really time ago. So we didn’t. I just love telling your funny stories about Mr.FFF. That’s all.

Back to Fro Yo.

Pineapple Coconut Frozen Yogurt - A super easy, healthy dessert for Summer! | Food Faith Fitness| #frozenyogurt #recipe #healthy

How do you guys feel about Frozen Yogurt? Do you like it better than ice cream? Less than Ice cream?

Personally, I love it more. Especially when you go to Menchies and make a fro yo sundae bigger than your head. <3

Sidenote: Have you BEEN to Menchies? It’s like Marble Slab Creamery, but better. You get to build your own soft serve fro yo sundae, and you pay by weight. They have the BEST topping too – Like Circus Animals.  Ya’ll know how I feel about Circus Animals with Ice Cream.  I die.

Longest side note of life right there.

Anyway.  We’ve made a few Ice cream Recipes here on FFF, but no Fro Yo.

Is it ok that I think I just rhymed “no” with “yo?” I’m not sure.

So, here I am presenting you with the EASIEST recipe EVER….that is also delicious and SUPA summery.

Basically, I am giving you a Pina Colada, in a healthy, creamy dessert form.

So, you know what they say:

Pineapple Coconut Frozen Yogurt - A super easy, healthy dessert for Summer! | Food Faith Fitness| #frozenyogurt #recipe #healthy

“If you like Pina Coladas, and dancing in the rain….”

Dancing in the rain is optional though.

Head on over to Whole Yum to get the Pineapple and Coconut Frozen Yogurt Recipe!

And, don’t forget to enter the $1000 cash giveaway!

 Want more frozen desserts?

Strawberry Freeze

Strawberry Freeze

Vegan Rum 'N "Egg Nog" Ice Cream

Vegan Rum ‘N “Egg Nog” Ice Cream

Skinny Frozen Carrot Cake Cheesecake

Healthy Frozen Carrot Cake Cheesecake

Subscribe to email updates to get a FREE E-cookbook!!


  1. says

    I didn’t know you could make this so easily! So great! I love Menchie’s! Have you tried the cheesecake bites? After yesterday’s post I’m thinking you’ll love them if you haven’t had them!

  2. says

    That’s so funny about your husband! Did he predict that you were going to make this frozen yogurt? :) Looks amazing! I’ve made my own ice cream before, but never frozen yogurt, so definitely trying this one out! Beautiful pics, too!

    • Taylor Kiser says

      Haha no he didn’t…guess his abilities are a little rusty! 😉
      Thanks Gayle, you’ll love this! It’s so easy!

    • Taylor Kiser says

      I am the same, they are both so good! Thanks so much Kristine, I really didn’t know it would be so easy either! :)

  3. says

    Oh my gosh! Love all your little side notes. My husband would love me a million times more if I made this for him…. So I pinned it and will definitely be trying it soon!

    • Taylor Kiser says

      I am glad you enjoyed the sidenotes! Thanks Carisa, if you make it please let me know how to goes!

  4. says

    Hehehe Taylor, I can totally relate to your man. I do the same thing all the time with my GF. But instead of pretending I can predict the future, I tell her that we’re telepathic but I’m the only one aware of this… 😉

    Loving this frozen yogurt: simple, healthy, fresh and yummy. A total winner!

    • Taylor Kiser says

      Haha that is hilarious Mike, it must be a guy thing that I was unaware of! 😉
      Thanks for the fro yo love!

  5. says

    Why do husbands always prefer the less healthy route when it comes to food? And when you suggest the healthier option their psychic abilities kick in and they suddenly knew we were going to ask that. I can totally relate. I love this pineapple coconut frozen yogurt. I don’t usually add coconut milk to mine, but I love the addition! Pinned!

    • Taylor Kiser says

      I don’t know?! UGH! Sometimes my hubs does so well, and other times..mega fail.
      Thanks Danae, the coconut milk adds a nice subtle flavour!! :)

  6. Brittney says

    You are so funny! haha
    This recipe looks so easy and delicious! Will be trying it out soon for sure!!

  7. Charlotte Moore says

    So funny!!!! Just wait until you have had 47 years together.

    Love coconut and pineapple together or by themselves. I love ice cream.

  8. says

    I love your funny stories about Mr FFF keep them coming!
    This looks so perfect. I am an equal opportunity frozen dessert consumer – gelato, ice cream, frozen yoghurt, sorbet – they all get my love. I’ve never made frozen yoghurt before though, so this sounds like a great weekend treat! Thanks Taylor :)

    • Taylor Kiser says

      Haha good! I am glad you enjoy them!
      HAHA @ equal opportunity – too funny! Fro yo is so easy, you must try it! Thanks for the love Amy! :)

  9. Shashi @ RunninSrilankan(dot)com says

    Ok, so I have been to Menchies, with that said I think I would much rather have your pina colada-esque fro yo!
    I am severely lactose intolerant, so I always always pick fro yo over ice cream – as much fro me as for those around me 😉

    • Taylor Kiser says

      Now THAT is a compliment because I LOVE Menchies!
      I remember you saying your lactose intolerant! SO SAD! Have you ever tried the Lactaid ice cream????

      • Shashi @ RunninSrilankan(dot)com says

        It’s not so bad – it’s been so long, I’ve gotten used to it – I have tried Lactaid ice cream – but there are like 2 flavors at my grocery store – so I stick to Kemps Moose tracks fro yo – so so good!

        • Taylor Kiser says

          Oh 2?! That is the worst!
          I remember your post on that – I LOVE Moose Tracks so I must locate this! So happy you have something you can eat!! :)

  10. Julia Weese says

    Curious, even though it is such a small amount, what purpose does the alcohol (vodka) serve? I don’t mind the booze but I would need to be mindful of who I am making this for. Thanks! This sounds so good, can’t wait to give it a try. Take care!

    • Taylor Kiser says

      Thanks Julia!
      Alcohol has a low freezing point which helps to keep lower fat ice creams/fro yo’s creamy because it doesn’t freeze all the way. You CAN omit it, but your frozen yogurt with definitely be a lot harder, especially if you use fat-free or reduced-fat fro yo!

  11. says

    I think I actually like frozen yogurt more than ice cream! Welllll, I don’t know, they are both delicious! It seems that frozen yogurt is a bit lighter than ice cream though, no?

    Thanks for sharing the recipe! i’ve been wanting an easy, frozen treat to make with the kiddos this summer, and I’ll have to try this one. Pina Colada flavor is amazing! :)

    • Taylor Kiser says

      Yes! It is definitely lighter. I like it too, it’s got a tartness that I love!
      Thanks Amber, I hope they like it! Just remember there is vodka in there! :)

  12. says

    My feelings on frozen yogurt = love + borderline obsessed. FROYO for life!
    This recipe looks so yummy, I’ll have to try it out asap, also love that you used that pan for it, why haven’t I thought of that?!? lol! The pictures are gorgeous as always!

    • Taylor Kiser says

      Haha well then you will love this girlfriend!
      The pan makes easy storage and pretty pics – thank you friend! :)

  13. says

    I am utterly obsessed with all things pineapple and coconut, these are SUCH great summer flavors! Can we add rum for an “adult” frozen yogurt treat ? 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>